Member Login

Logging In
Invalid username or password.
Incorrect Login. Please try again.

not a member? sign-up now!

Signing up could earn you gear and it helps to keep offensive content off of our site.

3-D Chart Plotting Benefits

Three-dimensional chart plotting is controversial and complex but has the potential to be an intuitive solution while under way.
Boating Safety

Three-dimensional charting may be the multifunction display feature seen the most in advertisements but used the least in the real world. In fact, a surprising number of generally knowledgeable navigators who post comments on my blog dismiss it as a marketing gimmick. But while it’s true the early versions of 3-D weren’t good for much more than trying to impress your marina mates, I believe that most of the MFD manufacturers have developed their 3-D presentations to the point where you ought to give them a serious try — even if it means reexamining the way you’ve always navigated!

Whether you learned marine navigation from a course or on a parent’s knee, 50 years ago or last summer, the lessons almost undoubtedly centered on paper charts. And for most of the short history of electronic charting, the goal was to duplicate digitally the information-rich paper chart over which your boat was constantly plotted. As that goal was pretty well accomplished, and much appreciated, along came optional overlays such as photo maps, points of interest, radar, weather and AIS. Though often pooh-poohed at first, all of those features are well-liked by many boaters today.

Navigation has changed a lot. But for most practitioners it’s all happened within the constraints of a traditional top-down, two-dimensional chart view that, in truth, is more about the limitations of the printing press than what’s ideal when you’re trying to work your way through hazardous waters.

What makes 3-D charting unprintable is that your display computes an ever-changing point of view (POV) unique to your boat’s location and heading. The typical bird’s-eye image puts you several hundred feet above the helm, and slightly behind it, looking forward at charted information and overlays that have been shaped and shaded with bathymetric and topographic information to simulate how they might really look, though augmented in ways meant to help you avoid mishaps. Underwater dangers may be brightly color-coded, or lit navaids may graphically indicate their color and pattern so you can confirm them against reality without having to read their characteristics. The vessel-centered look-ahead POV means you get to see more detail immediately around you, where you need it, without losing a sense of what’s coming up, as though you were viewing two or more zoom levels or chart scales at once.

Perhaps most important, though, is the way 3-D makes chart and overlay data more naturally correlate with what you’re actually seeing from your helm as you move through the water, so that it’s easier to make the correct connections. However, it’s fairly freaky how different 3-D is from the conventional 2-D view, and I know numerous boaters who’ve tried it just once, at a dock. That’s a mistake, because 3-D really shines when under way, while 2-D does remain the sensible mode in which to plan a voyage when tied up. A north-up, top-down view lets you look around a chart without losing overall orientation, and no one particular spot needs your bird’s-eye focus until you’re moving. In practice, creating a route over a traditional chart view, and then running it in 3-D, can go together like lobster and butter. That’s why adjusting a route in 2-D but driving it in 3-D is standard operating procedure when it comes to electronic automobile navigation. It’s just that when you climb into your car, you don’t have to overcome centuries of powerful tradition to look at a 3-D map.

This summer I tussled with my own decades of navigation habits by using 3-D views on four different multifunction displays, and I’ll be testing the feature in PC charting programs before winter closes in (all discussed in more detail on my blog). I am by no means a total convert, but 3-D is certainly not just a marketing gimmick. I believe that the manufacturers are working hard to perfect 3-D navigation because they’re convinced that it will become highly desirable for underway route-running — once we open our minds to it — and I think they’re right. But the jury is certainly out on what 3-D perfection looks like.

post a comment
NAME required